What to Take for Constipation: Store-Bought vs Natural Options
Share

Most store-bought constipation medicines fall into four groups. Fiber, like Metamucil, adds bulk. Stool softeners, like Colace, add moisture. Osmotic laxatives, like MiraLAX, pull water into the bowel. Stimulant laxatives, like Dulcolax tablets and senna, prompt the bowel to move. Natural options include food, water, psyllium, magnesium and herbal blends. None is right for everyone, so match the choice to how fast you need help and how often constipation happens.
Stand in the laxative aisle for a minute and it is easy to feel lost. There are powders, pills, chews, softeners and teas, and the boxes all promise relief. People often ask me, "Which one should I take?"
My honest answer is that most of these products work, and each one has a place. They just work in different ways and at different speeds. In this guide I will lay them side by side, fairly, so you can choose what fits you and talk with your pharmacist or doctor with confidence.
Before you reach for any product, remember that water, food and movement come first. My step-by-step guide to relieving constipation covers those basics.
What Are the Main Types of Constipation Medicine?
Almost every product falls into one of these groups:
- Bulk-forming fiber. Soaks up water to make stool bigger and softer. Examples: psyllium (Metamucil) and methylcellulose (Citrucel).
- Stool softeners. Help water mix into stool so it is less dry. Example: docusate (Colace).
- Osmotic laxatives. Pull water into the bowel to soften stool. Examples: polyethylene glycol 3350 (MiraLAX) and magnesium products like milk of magnesia.
- Stimulant laxatives. Prompt the muscles of the colon to move. Examples: bisacodyl (Dulcolax tablets) and senna (Senokot).
- Suppositories. Placed in the rectum to help stool pass quickly. Examples: glycerin and bisacodyl suppositories.
How Do the Popular Options Compare?
Here is a plain side-by-side look. Times are rough guides, and everyone is a little different.
| Option | How it works | Usual time to work | Good to know |
|---|---|---|---|
| MiraLAX (polyethylene glycol 3350) | Pulls water into stool | Often 1 to 3 days | Mixes into a drink with no taste. Label says not to use more than 7 days unless your doctor says so. |
| Dulcolax tablets (bisacodyl) | Stimulates the colon | Usually 6 to 12 hours | Often taken at bedtime. Can cause cramps. |
| Colace (docusate) | Softens stool | Often 1 to 3 days | Gentle. Often used to avoid straining, such as after surgery. |
| Metamucil (psyllium fiber) | Adds bulk and holds water | Often 1 to 3 days | Needs a full glass of water. Can cause gas at first. |
| Milk of magnesia (magnesium hydroxide) | Pulls water into the bowel | Often 30 minutes to 6 hours | Ask your doctor first if you have kidney problems. |
| Senna (Senokot, teas, blends) | Plant-based colon stimulant | Usually 6 to 12 hours | An herb found in many store-bought and natural products. |
| Glycerin suppository | Helps stool pass from the rectum | Often 15 to 60 minutes | Useful when stool is low and ready to come out. |
Always read and follow the label, and ask your pharmacist if you take other medicines. Products can interact with each other and with prescriptions.
When Does MiraLAX Make Sense?
MiraLAX is an osmotic laxative. It holds water in the bowel so stool stays soft. It has no taste or grit, which many people like. It tends to work slowly and gently, often over one to three days, so it is not usually the choice for same-day relief. Some people notice bloating or loose stools.
If you want to see how it compares with other choices, I wrote about MiraLAX vs senna and MiraLAX vs Metamucil.
When Does Dulcolax Make Sense?
Dulcolax tablets contain bisacodyl, a stimulant laxative. They are often taken at bedtime and work overnight. They can be helpful when you need a more predictable result. The most common side effect is belly cramping. Note that the Dulcolax name is also used on other products, including stool softeners, so check the active ingredient on the box.
When Does Colace Make Sense?
Colace is a stool softener. It does not make you go so much as make it easier to go. Doctors often suggest it when straining should be avoided, like after surgery or childbirth, or for people with hemorrhoids. On its own, many people find it too mild for stubborn constipation. My article on senna vs stool softener explains the difference.
What About Fiber Supplements?
Fiber supplements like psyllium are a good daily choice if your diet is low in fiber. They work slowly and help shape a soft, well-formed stool. The keys are to start low, add slowly and drink plenty of water. If you already eat a lot of fiber and still feel stuck, more fiber may not be the answer. See constipation from too much fiber.
What Natural Options Can You Take?
Many people want to start with something natural. Here are the choices I trust most:
- Food and water. Prunes, kiwi, pears, oatmeal, flax and chia, with plenty of water.
- Psyllium husk. A plant-based fiber you can buy plain.
- Magnesium. Citrate or oxide forms, if your doctor agrees.
- Senna. A plant leaf that has been used for a very long time and is still the active ingredient in many store-bought laxatives.
- Herbal blends. Products that combine senna with other herbs like cascara sagrada and cape aloe, often with warming herbs such as ginger.
I go into each of these in natural laxatives: what works, what to skip and what I recommend.
How Do You Choose What to Take?
Ask yourself these four simple questions:
- How fast do I need help? For today, a glycerin suppository or a stimulant at bedtime. For gentle help over a few days, fiber, a softener or MiraLAX.
- How often does this happen? Once in a while is different from most weeks. If it happens often, focus on daily habits and a plan you can stick with.
- What else do I take? Some medicines cause constipation, and some interact with laxatives. Your pharmacist can check.
- What does my body handle well? If fiber makes you bloated, try another type. If one product cramps you, a gentler one may suit you better.
"There is no single best laxative. There is the one that fits your body, your schedule and your health."
Dr. Jennifer Daniels
If you need relief right now, see how to relieve constipation fast. If you are sitting on the toilet as you read this, my guide to what to do when you are stuck on the toilet is for you.
When Should You See a Doctor?
Please call your doctor if you notice:
- Blood in your stool, or black, tarry stool
- Severe or constant belly pain
- Weight loss you cannot explain
- A sudden change in your bowel habits
- Constipation that lasts more than a couple of weeks
- Vomiting, or you cannot pass gas at all
- You need a laxative more than a few times a week to go
Also talk with your doctor before taking any laxative if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, have kidney or heart disease, or take prescription medicines. Laxatives for children should only be used as a doctor directs.
What Questions Do People Ask Most?
What is the best medicine for constipation?
There is no single best one. Fiber and MiraLAX work gently over a few days. Stimulant laxatives like Dulcolax tablets and senna usually work overnight. Glycerin suppositories work fastest. The best choice depends on how fast you need help, how often it happens and what else you take.
What over-the-counter constipation medicine works fastest?
Glycerin or bisacodyl suppositories usually work fastest, often within 15 to 60 minutes. Stimulant tablets like Dulcolax and senna usually work overnight. MiraLAX, Colace and fiber often take one to three days.
Is MiraLAX or Dulcolax better?
They work differently. MiraLAX pulls water into the bowel and works gently over one to three days. Dulcolax tablets stimulate the colon and usually work overnight but can cause cramps. Your pharmacist can help you decide which fits you.
Is a stool softener the same as a laxative?
Not quite. A stool softener like Colace helps water mix into stool so it is easier to pass, but it does not push stool along. Laxatives like MiraLAX or senna help move stool out. Some products combine both.
Are natural options as good as store-bought ones?
Some natural options, like senna, are the same active ingredient used in store-bought laxatives. Food, water and fiber help many people on their own. The best choice is the one that works gently for you and that you can use safely.
Where Do Vitality Capsules Fit?

Store-bought options can help you today. Vitality Capsules are made for the days after: herbal support for daily regularity, with eight herbs, including senna, cascara sagrada and cape aloe, plus garlic, ginger, clove, barberry and turmeric.* You take one capsule with dinner and a full glass of water. Many people notice a difference by the next morning, though results vary. If nothing happens, take two the next night, then stay at the amount that keeps you going every day, and never more than the label says.
Made in a GMP-certified facility in California, third-party tested, with no fillers, and trusted since 2006. Every bottle has 90 capsules and a 90-day money-back guarantee. Not for use if you are pregnant, breastfeeding or on blood thinners, and not for children. If you take any medicine or have a health condition, talk with your doctor first.
This article is for general education and is not medical advice. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Talk with your doctor before starting any new supplement, especially if you are pregnant, nursing, take medication or have a health condition.